Applicant Screening Process
The Screening Committee As A Hiring Practice
Screening committees shall be used for faculty, administrative, and
administrative support positions. Screening committees are not required
for other types of positions. The appropriate deans are responsible for
the selection and recommendation to the President for secretarial/clerical/technical
positions. In some instances, however, the appropriate dean may use a
screening committee for secretarial/clerical/technical positions. In these
instances, the same committee process will be followed (except that these
positions will be advertised internally for one week prior to being advertised
publicly).
The screening process involves evaluating applicants and determining
which applicants best meet the requirements of a position. The decision
is based upon a set of objective criteria which the appropriate dean and/or
the President believe must be present in order for the job to be performed
satisfactorily. The chance of making a poor hiring decision is greatly
reduced when appropriate methods of evaluation and selection are utilized.
Where applicable, when a vacancy arises that requires the use of a screening
committee and the time for selection is critically short, the appropriate
dean may recommend a Letter of Appointment until the screening/selection
process can be completed. A Letter of Appointment does not give the individual
preference toward any regular, full-time position.
THE SCREENING COMMITTEE PROCESS:
MAJOR STEPS
- Notification of Available Position:
The process of selecting faculty or staff begins once a personnel
need and the budgetary support to fill an existing or newly created
position has been determined by the appropriate dean and/or the President.
The division chair, in consultation with the appropriate dean, prepares
a "Notification of Available Position." Once the "Notification"
is approved by the appropriate dean, the President, and the Dean of
Financial Services, the Personnel Office is authorized to post and
advertise the position.
- Appointment of the Committee:
The President, in consultation with the appropriate dean, will appoint
members of the screening committee and its chair in writing. Screening
committees should be made up of 5 to 7 members with the option of
additional members being included where deemed appropriate. Screening
committees for faculty and administrative positions will be comprised
of professional (faculty and/or administrative) employees. In addition,
in an effort to promote diversity among Lee College employees, every
screening committee will include at least one ethnic minority, and
every faculty screening committee will include a member from the opposite
instructional area. Every effort should be made to increase diversity
on the committee by considering such factors as gender, age, and disability.
Individuals who are not Lee College employees shall not
serve on committees.
The screening committee should be formed and charged prior to the
closing date for applications.
- Position Announcement:
The Personnel Office will prepare and post the "Position Announcement."
Employment criteria shall be clearly defined in the position announcement
and must be objective and directly related to the job to be performed
and to essential duties related to the position. The announcement
must distinguish between requirements and preferences. The announcement
will identify the required application materials to be submitted,
including a cover letter, resume, copies of transcripts, contact information
on three (3) professional references, foreign transcripts evaluation
and, where desired, a statement of teaching philosophy. The announcement
will also contain information concerning the starting date and information
on beginning compensation. A closing date, a statement that the closing
date is to be determined, or a statement that the vacancy shall remain
open until the position is filled will be included.
The position announcement shall reflect the institution's commitment
to equal employment opportunity to encourage a diverse applicant pool.
The Personnel Office may advertise in appropriate local, national,
and professional publications to enlarge the pool of candidates.
Once a position is advertised, it should be acted on in a timely
fashion.
- The Applicant Pool:
Applications shall be reviewed by the Personnel Officer to ensure
that the individuals included for interview meet the minimum advertised
criteria for the position in terms of education and applicable work
experience. If questions arise regarding course and/or degree equivalence
or other questions of interpretation, the appropriate dean should
be consulted. The Personnel Officer will verify compliance with college,
state, and federal requirements.
In screening and selecting applicants, screening committees should
look at the total person and what he or she has to offer regarding
knowledge, skills, and abilities. Qualifications for the job should
be the determining factors throughout the process.
- Screening Committee:
The screening committee will act on behalf of the institution to
evaluate credentials, conduct employment interviews, and recommend
candidates to the appropriate dean and the President. All work
of the committee must be conducted in strictest confidence. However,
screening committees may choose to allow access to teaching demonstrations,
but not interviews or committee meetings, to Lee College employees
not serving on screening committees.
- Recommendation for employment:
Upon the final decision of the President to recommend a prospective
employee to the Board, the appropriate dean should initiate the "Faculty/Administrative
Recommendation" form. The appropriate dean will sign the form
as "Recommending;" the President will sign the form "Approving;"
and the Personnel Officer will sign the form, signifying that the
proper salary grade and step has been assigned. This form, along with
the "President's Check-Off List for New Hires" and the prospective
employee's credentials will be forwarded to the President for inclusion
in the Board packet.
VERIFICATION OF CREDENTIALS, REFERENCES, AND PAST EMPLOYMENT
Previous employment references are checked a total of three (3) times.
- The screening committee initiates the process by checking
references prior to submitting the finalists' names for the position
to the appropriate dean. This check ensures that each candidate sent
forward for an interview with the appropriate dean is a viable applicant.
Credentials and transcripts should be evaluated to ensure that the individual
meets the minimum SACS educational requirements. If questions come up
in this regard, the appropriate dean should be consulted.
- The appropriate dean, once his/her interviews are complete,
shall check the employment references of the candidate(s) being recommended
to the President. This check will include evaluation and verification
of the individual's academic credentials. This check allows the dean
the opportunity to learn valuable information about the candidate(s)
to support the recommendation of the finalist(s).
- The Personnel Officer makes a final reference check.
Employment history and credentials are checked in addition to a criminal
history check and verification of the accreditation of the institution
from which the highest degree is attained.
APPROVAL FOR EMPLOYMENT:
Once the documentation for employment recommendations are completed and
signed, the candidate's name shall be placed on the next Agenda for Board
approval. Candidates for Faculty, Administrative, or Administrative Support
positions shall not start to work without Board approval.
Candidates for secretarial/clerical/technical or classified staff positions
shall not start to work without the President's signature
on the "Approval to Hire" form.
DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES
- Statement of Philosophy:
In accordance with standard hiring practices at colleges across
the United States, a screening committee composed of Lee College
employees will be formed in each discipline or division in which
a vacancy exists. This committee will have the responsibility to
evaluate credentials, conduct employment interviews, screen applicants,
and make employment recommendations to the appropriate dean and
the President. This process will be conducted consistently with
existing state and federal laws, and Lee College policy. In order
to preserve a professional image, all work of the committee will
be conducted in strict confidence. However, screening committees
may choose to allow access to teaching demonstrations to Lee College
employees not serving on the screening committee.
Effective selection involves the appropriate dean, President, Personnel/EEO/AAP
Office, division chair, and screening committee working together as
a team. Each individual on the team plays an integral part in ensuring
a quality hiring process is followed, a process that will secure the
most appropriate candidate for the position.
Since Lee College highly values the candidate selection process,
it should be given priority status. Specifically, the President, deans,
division chairs, Personnel Office, and screening committees should
act in a timely manner.
- The President will have the following responsibilities relating
to the employment function:
- Assess the need for additional/replacement personnel.
- Approve the "Notification of Available Position."
- Appoint the screening committees in consultation with the appropriate
dean.
- Send letters requesting professsional employees to serve
on committees.
- If a position has been delayed, notify the Personnel Officer
in a timely manner.
- Conduct final interview of candidate(s). Make final employment
decision.
- Make applicable employment recommendation to Board.
- The appropriate Dean will have the following responsibilities
relating to the employment process:
- Refer all inquiries regarding the selection process to the Personnel
Office.
- In consultation with the division chair, assess the need for
additional/replacement personnel.
- If a position has been delayed, notify the Personnel Officer
in a timely manner.
- In consultation with the Personnel Officer and division chair,
define the qualifications for the position and draft/update the
position description.
- In consultation with the division chair, initiate and complete
the "Notification of Available Position," secure appropriate
signatures, and forward to the President.
- Consult with the President regarding the composition of the screening
committee.
- The appropriate dean may meet with screening committees regarding
academic and instructional issues.
- Review application materials of all candidates to be interviewed
to verify that they meet the minimum advertised criteria for the
position. Notify screening committee chair of any concerns or objections
in a timely manner.
- Authorize the reimbursement of a maximum of $350 for travel expenses
to a maximum of five (5) candidates per position who travel from
at least a 250 mile distance for the initial interview.
- Ensure that all copies of application materials are returned
to the Personnel Office.
- III-1
- Ensure that the committee narrows the applicant pool to a maximum
of five (5) candidates per position for interview, and makes its
recommendations through fair and equitable procedures.
- Conduct interviews of candidate(s) recommended by the screening
committee and make appropriate recommendations to the President.
- Upon final employment recommendation, generate the "Faculty/Administrative
Recommendation" form for approval by the President prior to
making the employment recommendation to the Board.
- A checklist is provided in Section IV for the Division Chair/Director.
The division chair/director will have the following responsibilities
relating to the employment function:
- Refer all inquiries regarding the selection process to the Personnel
Office.
- In consultation with faculty/professional employees in the division,
assess the need for additional/replacement personnel, define the
position requirements, draft the position description, and recommend
action to the appropriate dean.
- Where appropriate, make preliminary contacts to screen for potential
candidates at professional conferences and/or appoint a designee
to do so.
- In consultation with the appropriate dean, generate "Notification
of Available Position" and secure appropriate signatures.
- If serving on screening committee, work with members to conduct
telephone conferences, review applications, and select a maximum
of five (5) candidates for interview per job position.
- If serving on screening committee, work with members to conduct
employment interviews.
- Upon final employment decision, work with screening committee
chair to prepare all materials necessary for Faculty/Administrative
Recommendation; forward to appropriate dean and Personnel Officer
for completion and signatures. Ensure these documents are forwarded
to the President's office for presentation to the Board.
- A checklist is provided in Section IV for the Screening Committee
Chair. The screening committee chair will have the following responsibilities
relating to the employment function:
- Refer all inquiries regarding the selection process to the Personnel
Office.
- Where appropriate, make preliminary contacts to screen for potential
candidates at professional conferences and/or appoint designees
to do so.
- Appoint or direct the committee to elect a secretary to maintain
minutes. Minutes of the screening committee meetings should include
what items were discussed but not the opinions of individual members.
- Work with the committee to develop a tentative timeline to guide
the screening process.
- Conduct or appoint one or more committee members to conduct the
initial screening. In order for applicants to be considered for
a position, they should meet the minimum advertised requirements
as stated in the position announcement.
"Degrees in progress" should not be considered if an academic
degree is required for the position. If questions arise regarding
course and/or degree equivalence, or other questions of interpretation,
the appropriate dean should be consulted. If applicants have not
submitted all application requirements requested in the position
advertisement, they can be contacted to supply the missing documentation
only if this is done for all applicants who have omitted a specified
requirement.
- Notify Personnel Office of all candidates eliminated from consideration.
- Work with committee to develop a list of questions and suggested
topics for writing assignments to be asked of all candidates. Forward
list of questions and suggested topics for writing assignments to
Personnel Officer for approval prior to any interviews being
conducted.
- Work with the committee to review applications/resumes and conduct
telephone interviews as necessary to limit the applicant pool to
the maximum of five candidates to be interviewed per position.
- Send application materials of finalists to division chair (if
he/she is not serving on the committee) and to the appropriate dean
or the Personnel Officer for their review.
- Work with committee to schedule interviews, carefully planning
all aspects of campus visits, especially logistics and scheduling.
- Notify the appropriate dean, division chair, and Personnel Officer
of interview schedule, time, and place.
- Request that Personnel Office send applications, copy of benefits,
travel reimbursement form, Employee Handbook, and self-addressed,
stamped envelope in which to return application to all candidates
selected for interviewing.
- Ensure that the proper Lee College application is completed prior
to the interview. The completed application may be brought to the
interview.
- Work with committee to conduct videotaped interviews including
teaching demonstrations for faculty candidates. All candidates should
be asked the same questions during the interview. However, follow-up
questions are permissible.
- Work with committee to administer writing assignments to all
candidates from topics selected from their teaching discipline or
area of expertise.
- Conduct reference checks to verify employment dates, job performance,
etc.
- Work with committee to determine candidates for recommendation
to the division chair (if he/she is not serving on the committee),
the appropriate dean, and the President. Guidelines outlining how
candidates may be ranked are included in Section IV of the manual
as options for use by members of the screening committee
- Upon final employment decision, work with division chair to prepare
all materials necessary for Faculty/Administrative Recommendation.
Forward materials to the appropriate dean, division chair, and the
Personnel Officer for completion and signatures.
- Complete the "President's Check-Off List for New Hires."
- Original applications/resumes should not leave the Personnel
Office. Following Board's approval of hire, return to the Personnel
Office or destroy all copies of candidates' application materials.
- The Screening Committee will have the following responsibilities
relating to the employment function:
- Refer all inquiries regarding the selection process to the Personnel
Office.
- Where appropriate, make preliminary contacts to screen for potential
candidates at professional conferences.
- Work with committee chair to elect/appoint a secretary who will
maintain minutes of all meetings. Minutes of the screening committee
meetings should include what items were discussed but not the opinions
of individual members.
- Work with committee chair to develop a tentative timeline to
guide the screening process.
- Work with committee chair to conduct the initial screening. In
order for applicants to be considered for a position, they should
meet the minimum advertised requirements as stated in the position
announcement. "Degrees in progress" should not be
considered if an academic degree is required for the position. If
questions arise regarding course and/or degree equivalence, or other
questions of interpretation, the appropriate dean should be consulted.
If applicants have not submitted all application requirements requested
in the position advertisement, they can be contacted to supply the
missing documentation only if this is done for all applicants
who have omitted a specified requirement.
- Work with committee chair to review applications/resumes and
conduct telephone interviews as necessary to screen applicant pool
to the maximum of five (5) candidates to be interviewed per position.
- Work with committee chair to develop a list of questions and
suggested topics for writing assignments to be asked of all candidates.
- Work with committee chair to invite candidates for interview.
Ensure that all communications to candidates portray a quality,
professional image of the institution. Carefully plan all aspects
of campus visits, especially logistics and scheduling.
- Work with committee chair to conduct interviews including a required
videotaped teaching demonstration for faculty candidates. All candidates
should be asked the same questions during the interview. However,
follow-up questions are permissible.
- Work with committee chair to administer writing assignments to
all candidates from topics selected from their teaching discipline
or area of expertise.
- Work with committee chair to determine candidates for recommendation
to the appropriate dean and the President. Guidelines outlining
how candidates may be ranked are included in Section IV of the manual
as options for use by members of the screening committee.
- The Personnel Officer will have the following responsibilities
relating to the employment function:
- Prepare and post "Position Announcements," using job
criteria provided in the "Notification of Available Position"
for faculty and for non-instructional personnel. Provide copies
to the appropriate dean and division chair for review.
- Place job advertisements in appropriate local, state, national,
and trade publications.
- Mail "Position Announcements" to Black and Hispanic
Educational Access committees, to appropriate colleges and universities,
and to professional organizations and publications which might reach
a diverse pool of qualified candidates.
- Receive and "log" applications; acknowledge receipt
of application materials in writing and send to all applicants a
Statistical Data Form with a postage paid, self-addressed
return envelope.
- Communicate with candidates by telephone or mail at all key points
during the search process. Ensure that all communications to candidates
portray a quality, professional image of the institution.
- Review application materials to ensure all candidates selected
for interview meet the minimum advertised job criteria. Discuss
in a timely fashion any questions of interpretation with the appropriate
dean.
- Function as a non-voting member of all screening committees to
ensure compliance with college, state, and federal requirements.
- Meet with committee members prior to the closing date for applications
to "charge" them regarding their responsibilities in the
screening process with respect to current laws and guidelines.
- Provide all committee members with an Employment Procedures
Handbook.
- Review all interview questions submitted by the committee prior
to any interviews being conducted.
- Notify candidates if a position is not filled or is delayed and
is to be re-advertised.
- Upon advisement of the screening committee, notify all applicants
who do not meet minimum qualifications of the status of their application.
- Send a Lee College Application, copy of benefits, travel reimbursement
form, Employee Handbook, and self-addressed, stamped envelope in
which to return application to all candidates selected for interviewing.
- Review any application materials of finalists that are forwarded
to the Personnel Office by the screening committee; report back
to screening committee chair in a timely manner if there are objections
to any of the finalists being interviewed.
- Personnel Officer may sit in on interviews with finalists.
- Ensure that the proper Lee College application form is completed
prior to interviews being conducted. Completed application may be
brought to the interview.
- Ensure that all employment materials are prepared for Board approval.
- Extend formal, written employment offer subject to policies and
procedures (and Board approval on all appointments requiring a contract).
- Notify all applicants who were not chosen for the position that
the position has been filled.
- Place new employees on the payroll and enroll them in all benefit
programs; ensure that all employment papers are completed and that
all credentials are on file.
- As appropriate, prepare employment contracts, and secure appropriate
signatures.
- Respond to all inquiries regarding the selection process.
- Authorize the reimbursement of a maximum of $350 of documented
travel expenses to no more than five (5) candidates per job position.
- Contingency Plans.
- If the selected candidate declines the employment offer or, if
after interviewing the candidates in the first round the committee
decides to consider additional candidates, the screening committee
will re-convene, and may:
- Recommend another candidate.
- Review the applications and select additional candidates for
the interview process.
- Repeat the screening process.
- Re-advertise the position (a) immediately, or (b) at a later
date.
- Employment of Classified Staff (Secretarial/Clerical/Technical and
Maintenance/Custodial Employees).
National advertising is not necessary for classified staff (non-exempt
employees). However, a similar screening process as outlined above
may be utilized for secretarial/clerical/technical positions.
The division chair/director will assess the need for additional/replacement
personnel. A "Notification of Available Position for Non-Instructional
Personnel" will be completed and approved by the appropriate
dean and the President.
The Personnel Officer will post and advertise the position internally
for one week prior to the position being advertised externally.
The position announcement will specifically state the internal and
external posting dates. The following language will be included
in all Position Announcements for Classified positions: NOTE: "If
the position is filled with an internal candidate, the position
may close prior to (this) deadline, and may not be opened to the
public." This procedure provides internal candidates with first
opportunity to apply, and have his/her application evaluated first,
but does not guarantee that any internal
candidates will automatically be the successful candidate.
The division chair/director will review all applications received
and will interview no more than five (5) candidates, conduct reference
checks, and make recommendations to the appropriate dean. The appropriate
dean will interview the recommended candidate, and make a recommendation
to the President. The President will make the final employment decision.
The division chair/director will initiate the "Approval to
Hire" form and will, in consultation with the Personnel Officer,
determine the correct salary placement on the scale. No candidate
will begin work until the "Approval to Hire" has been
signed by the appropriate dean, Personnel Officer, Dean of Financial
Services, and the President. Travel reimbursements will not
be made to candidates for classified positions.
- EMPLOYMENT BY "LETTER OF APPOINTMENT":
"Letters of Appointment" are defined in the Lee College
Board of Regents Policy DDA (local), as "Appointment
of personnel by the President, for terms as specified in the Letter
of Appointment".
Letters of Appointment apply only to administrative and instructional
personnel and are to be used only in cases of emergency and for
employees working with grants. Letters of Appointment are not to
be used for long-term employment, to replace "contract"
positions, nor to circumvent the "contract" employment
procedure. Letters of Appointment are to be used only in the following
employment contexts:
- Interagency contracts with state and federal units. (Example,
Texas Department of Criminal Justice). In these situations, the
committee process will be utilized.
- Emergency situations as defined by the President of Lee College.
- On a full-time basis, as defined by Policy DJ (local),
teach courses of anticipated duration of one academic year or
less. Should the courses extend beyond one academic year, the
committee process will then be considered. This does not give
the individual on a Letter of Appointment preference to the contract
position.
- Salaries are funded by external or "soft" money.
Employment on a "Letter of Appointment" does not require
Board approval.
Individuals hired on "Letter of Appointment" cannot enter
contract status until the full employment process has been conducted.
The employee hired on a "letter" may apply for the position
in competition with all other candidates but "courtesy"
interviews are not to be automatically granted. The "letter"
does not give the employee preference to any contract position.
The employee acknowledges this understanding by way of signature
of the "Letter" which states this explicitly.
- PART-TIME EMPLOYMENT:
It is not necessary to advertise for part-time employees if a sufficient
"applicant pool" is available. However, the position may
be advertised locally. Part-time employees will compete with all
other candidates for advertised full-time positions and are not
to be automatically offered "courtesy" interviews.
Part-time faculty must meet the same credential requirements
as full-time faculty.
Part-time employment is for a maximum of 19.5 hours per week, and
employees in this job category are not eligible for college benefits.
Because of Internal Revenue Service (IRS) regulations, once a student
is employed in a part-time position, he/she will no longer be eligible
to work as a Student Assistant.
Screening Committee Chair's Checklist
Refer all inquiries regarding the selection process to the Personnel
Office.
____ appoint or direct the committee to elect a secretary to maintain
minutes of all meetings
____ work with the committee to develop a tentative timeline to guide
the screening process
____ conduct or appoint one or more committee members to conduct the
initial screening to determine whether each candidate meets the minimum
advertised criteria. If questions arise regarding course and/or degree
equivalence, or other questions of interpretation, the appropriate Dean
should be consulted.
____ notify Personnel Officer of all candidates who do not meet the minimum
qualifications
____ work with committee to develop a list of questions and suggested
topics for writing assignments to be asked of all candidates
____ forward list of questions and suggested topics for writing assignments
to personnel officer for approval prior to any interviews being
conducted
____ work with the committee to review applications/resumes and conduct
telephone interviews as necessary to limit the applicant pool to the maximum
of five candidates to be interviewed per position
____ send application materials of finalists to division chair (if he/she
is not a member of the committee), the appropriate dean, and the Personnel
Officer for their review
____ schedule interviews with finalists
____ notify the Dean, Division Chair, and Personnel Officer of interview
schedule, time, and place
____ request that Personnel send applications, copy of benefits, travel
reimbursement form, Employee Handbook, and self-addressed, stamped envelope
in which to return application to all candidates selected for interviewing
____ arrange for videotape equipment
____ ensure that the proper Lee College application is completed prior
to the interview
____ work with committee to conduct interviews and administer writing
assignments
____ conduct reference checks to verify employment dates, job performance,
etc.
____ work with committee to determine candidates for recommendation to
the division chair (if he/she is not serving on the committee), the appropriate
dean, and the President
____ upon final employment decision, work with Division Chair to prepare
all materials necessary for
Faculty/Administrative Recommendation
____ forward materials to the Dean, Division Chair, and the Personnel
Officer for completion and signatures
____ complete the "President's Check-Off List for New Hires"
____ following Board's approval of hire, return to the personnel office
or destroy all copies of candidates' application materials
Division Chair/Director's Checklist
Refer all inquiries regarding the selection process to the Personnel
Office.
____ work with the Dean and faculty/professional employees in the division
to define the qualifications for the position and draft/update the position
description
____ in consultation with the appropriate Dean, generate "Notification
of Available Position"
____ secure appropriate signatures
____ if serving on the screening committee, work with members to
____ review applications
____ conduct telephone conferences with candidates
____ select a maximum of 5 finalists to be interviewed
____ conduct interviews
____ if not serving on the screening committee, work with the committee
chair to review the committee's recommendations
____ work with Screening Committee Chair to prepare materials necessary
for Faculty/Administrative Recommendation
____ ensure that documents are forwarded to the President's office for
presentation to the Board
|